The audit trail moves in-house: SEC proposes direct control of the CAT
The SEC has proposed to rescind Rule 613, take direct control of the consolidated audit trail and fund it through appropriations. Reporting duties for broker-dealers would stay substantially the same.
The SEC proposed on Nov. 20 to take direct control of the consolidated audit trail, the database that records every order, quote and trade in U.S. equities and listed options. The proposal would rescind Rule 613 of Regulation NMS, under which the exchanges and FINRA build and run the system, and replace it with a new Rule 17a-26 under the Exchange Act.
Under the new rule the self-regulatory organizations and broker-dealers would record and report substantially the same information they report today. The difference is the recipient. Reports would go to the Commission or to a party it designates, and the SEC would govern the system itself. Commissioner Mark Uyeda’s statement on the proposal says the Commission expects to fund the system through Congressional appropriations.
How the CAT got here
The audit trail was the SEC’s answer to the flash crash of May 6, 2010, when regulators needed months to reconstruct twenty minutes of trading from incompatible data sets. Rule 613, adopted in 2012, told the exchanges and FINRA to design a single system through a national market system plan. The plan was approved in 2016. Reporting was phased in over the following years.
The structure has been contested ever since. The self-regulatory organizations own and operate the system through a jointly held company and decide its budget. The SEC is its principal user and oversees the plan but does not run it. Broker-dealers supply the data and, through fees passed along by the SROs, much of the money. Uyeda’s statement says the arrangement has produced slow decisions, disputes over governance and funding, and higher operating costs.
Cost has been the sharpest issue. Annual operating costs were estimated at about $55 million when the plan was approved in 2016. By 2024 the projected budget was approaching $250 million. The allocation of those costs to broker-dealers produced litigation, and the Eleventh Circuit vacated the SEC’s 2023 funding order in July 2025.
Uyeda described the proposal as a way to line up responsibility for governing and funding the system with responsibility for overseeing and using it.
What changes for a broker-dealer
On the reporting side, little would change at first. Firms would continue to capture order events and submit them. Systems built for CAT reporting should carry over.
The changes are in three other places.
The first is fees. If the system is funded by appropriation, the CAT fees that firms now pay through their SROs should fall away or shrink. Whether Congress funds the system at the level it now costs is a separate question, and the answer will shape what the database can do.
The second is the rule that firms answer to. Reporting obligations that now arise under an NMS plan, and are enforced in the first instance by FINRA and the exchanges, would arise under a Commission rule. A reporting failure would be a violation of an Exchange Act rule.
The third is governance of the data. Customer information in the CAT has been a concern since the system was designed. Moving the database under direct Commission control places responsibility for its security with a single federal agency.
Why the data matters
The audit trail is one reason trading-based enforcement has become faster. Before the CAT, linking a pattern of well-timed trades to a single person across several brokers took requests to each firm and weeks of matching. The proposal changes who owns the system and who pays for it, and leaves in place what it collects.
What happens next
The proposal is open for public comment and has no effect until the Commission adopts a final rule. Three questions are likely to dominate the comment file: how the transition from the existing plan would be managed, what happens to costs already incurred and billed, and whether an appropriated budget would be stable from year to year.
Firms should not change their reporting in anticipation. They should review the proposal for its effect on fee accruals and on the supervisory procedures that cite the CAT NMS plan.
Sponsor’s view
From Andy Altahawi, Adamson Brothers Corp., the sponsor of this publication. I ran a broker-dealer for nearly a decade, and the cost of regulatory reporting falls hardest on the small firm. If the Commission is the main user of this system, it is reasonable that the Commission should govern it and answer for its budget. The comment period should be used to pin down the transition, because firms have built their compliance around the current plan.
Prepared with AI assistance from public sources and reviewed under our editorial policy. Not investment advice.